Usually not, and rarely for the reason people want one. Parents often hope an evaluation will finally have an expert name what their ex is, and that is not what evaluations reliably deliver. They are expensive, slow, and once ordered they typically examine both parents, so a request aimed at your ex can turn into a process that scrutinizes you. Evaluations also get used as a weapon: a request framed as concern for the children can be a way of asserting that you are the unstable one. Consider it only where a genuine, documented question about parenting capacity exists, and only with your attorney’s advice.
What people hope for versus what actually happens
The hope is a report that validates everything you have experienced. The reality is often an expensive process with a limited effect on the outcome. Been There Got Out is direct about how these evaluations tend to function in high-conflict cases.
Psychological evaluations are often used as a weapon in custody battles. Your ex may make this request in an effort to substantiate their assertion that you are the unstable one.
Been There Got Out, Toxic Relationships, High-Conflict Divorce, and How to Stay Sane Under Insane Circumstances
The cost is not trivial either. In BTGO’s reporting, attorney Dennis Vetrano noted that experts are sometimes paid twenty thousand dollars or more for reports that have little impact on a case.
It will look at you too
This is the part that surprises people. An order for a psychological evaluation usually covers both parents. If you have any history your ex is eager to raise, past therapy, medication, or a difficult period, you are inviting it into the record. That is not a reason for shame, and a history of getting help is defensible. It is a reason to make the decision with clear eyes rather than out of a wish to be vindicated.
When it may be worth it
Where there is a real, documented question about a parent’s capacity to care for a child safely, an evaluation can give the court something it cannot get from competing testimony. That is a narrow case, and it is a strategic call to make with your attorney, weighing cost, delay, and what the evaluation is likely to actually find.
Thinking through whether a request like this helps or hurts your position is the kind of call BTGO’s coaching works through. Use these answers at your own discretion.
Frequently asked questions
Should I ask the court for a psychological evaluation of my ex?
Usually not. They are expensive, slow, typically examine both parents, and rarely deliver the validation people hope for. Consider one only where there is a genuine documented question about parenting capacity, on your attorney’s advice.
Will a psychological evaluation prove my ex is a narcissist?
No. Evaluations assess parenting-relevant functioning, not a label you can hand the judge. Courts respond to documented behavior and its effect on the children far more than to a diagnostic term.
Does a psychological evaluation examine both parents?
Usually yes. An order commonly covers both, so a request aimed at your ex can result in your own history being scrutinized. Factor that in before requesting one.
How much does a psychological evaluation cost?
It varies widely, and it can be very expensive. BTGO has reported cases where experts were paid twenty thousand dollars or more for reports that had little effect on the outcome.
My ex requested an evaluation of me. What should I do?
Do not panic, and do not hide your history. Talk with your attorney, prepare with evidence of current stability and consistent parenting, and treat it as a chance to show how well you actually function.
Related: all answers in this topic · all answers · custody evaluations
